OHSL American Division
2004 Single Game Highs - Goals
| Date | Player | School | Goals | Opponent |
| 5/7/2004 | Markus Fallico | East Syracuse-Minoa | 6 | Oswego |
| 5/17/2004 | Kevin Curtin | Corcoran | 6 | Central Square |
| 4/13/2004 | Casey McLean | Corcoran | 5 | Cicero-North Syracuse |
| 4/27/2004 | Casey Martin | Fayetteville-Manlius | 5 | Oswego |
| 4/30/2004 | Markus Fallico | East Syracuse-Minoa | 5 | Henninger |
| 5/13/2004 | Kevin Nolan | Auburn | 5 | Oswego |
| 4/13/2004 | Chris Greenman | Nottingham | 4 | Baldwinsville |
| 4/13/2004 | David Jordan | Corcoran | 4 | Cicero-North Syracuse |
| 4/15/2004 | Jamie Settineri | Nottingham | 4 | Auburn |
| 4/15/2004 | Tim Burns | Nottingham | 4 | Auburn |