Frontier League
2004 Single Game Highs - Goals
| Date | Player | School | Goals | Opponent |
| 4/22/2004 | Greg Niewieroski | Watertown | 7 | South Jefferson |
| 5/4/2004 | Brendan Loftus | Watertown IHC | 7 | South Jefferson |
| 5/11/2004 | A.J. Vaughn | Watertown | 7 | Indian River |
| 4/1/2004 | Kenny Nims | Watertown | 6 | Watertown IHC |
| 4/29/2004 | Brendan Loftus | Watertown IHC | 6 | General Brown |
| 5/13/2004 | Justin Pecori | South Jefferson | 6 | Indian River |
| 5/13/2004 | A.J. Vaughn | Watertown | 6 | Carthage |
| 5/18/2004 | Kenny Nims | Watertown | 6 | Lowville |
| 5/18/2004 | Mario Ventiquattro | Carthage | 6 | South Jefferson |
| 3/30/2004 | Geoff Weaver | Carthage | 5 | Indian River |