OHSL Division II
2009 Single Game Highs - Goals
| Date | Player | School | Goals | Opponent |
| 4/7/2009 | Carl Zimmerman | Homer | 7 | Jordan-Elbridge |
| 4/21/2009 | Aaron Darr | Homer | 7 | Westhill |
| 5/21/2009 | Kevin Rice | Skaneateles | 6 | Jordan-Elbridge |
| 4/7/2009 | Dylan Tripodi | Westhill | 5 | Cazenovia |
| 4/7/2009 | Paul Armideo | Homer | 5 | Jordan-Elbridge |
| 5/12/2009 | Sean Cannizzaro | Cazenovia | 5 | Jordan-Elbridge |
| 4/6/2009 | Kelly Donigan | Skaneateles | 4 | Marcellus |
| 4/21/2009 | Tris Nicola | Westhill | 4 | Homer |
| 4/22/2009 | Sean Cannizzaro | Cazenovia | 4 | Marcellus |
| 5/7/2009 | Tim Burgess | Westhill | 4 | Cazenovia |
| 5/7/2009 | Dan Eipp | Westhill | 4 | Cazenovia |