Goalie Saves - 1959
| Player | School | Saves |
| Dave Hawley | Watertown | 54 |
| Steve Hackett | Irondequoit | 41 |
| Tom DeFazio | Geneva | 26 |
| Joe DeFazio | Geneva | 21 |
| Dave Valle | Baldwinsville | 19 |
| Dan Coughlin | West Genesee | 17 |
| DeFazio | Geneva | 11 |
| Dick Lindholm | Baldwinsville | 10 |
| Dave Valle | Watertown | 9 |
| Pete Jackson | Irondequoit | 5 |
| Bob Simon | Watertown | 5 |
| Dave Moracco | Geneva | 3 |